Idaho Teacher Acquitted of Animal Cruelty for Feeding Puppy to Turtle | Care2 Causes

One afternoon after school in March 2018, some students watched as Robert Crosland, a science teacher at Preston Junior High in Idaho, fed a live puppy to a snapping turtle. The turtle was later euthanized—not by Crosland, thankfully—because the teacher did not have a permit to keep it.

Outrage over this disturbing incident spread around the world, yet many of Crosland’s students and their parents defended him. Crosland was not suspended or fired from his job.

Jill Parrish, a former student of Crosland’s, received death threats after she reported the puppy killing to police. “This is a cut-and-dried case of animal cruelty,” she told the Idaho Statesman last year. “But they’re saying, ‘The teacher is a good teacher.’ Everybody loves him.”

One of those supporters is Farahlyn Hansen, the mother of two students who witnessed Crosland killing the puppy. She told last year that if anyone should be upset about it, it should be her, but that wasn’t the case. “I felt like it was the more humane thing for Robert to do than to just leave it to die,” Hansen said. “The puppy was dying.”

Another parent, Annette Salvesen, agreed with Hansen. “If it was a deformed puppy that was going to die anyway, Cros[land] is very much circle of life,” she said.
Be an informed activist.

Get fact-based insights about newsworthy causes delivered daily to your inbox.

Although about 4,000 people signed a petition supporting Crosland, more than 248,000 people signed a Care2 petition urging the teacher to be fired.

After a three-month investigation, the Idaho attorney general’s office charged Crosland with animal cruelty. Because this was Crosland’s first offense, under Idaho law it was a considered a misdemeanor. If he was found guilty, Crosland faced up to six months in jail and a $5,000 fine.

But nearly a year after he killed the puppy, a jury of Crosland’s peers has found him not guilty of animal cruelty—which really shouldn’t be too shocking, considering his support from the community. The trial at the Franklin County Courthouse in Preston lasted just two days—most of the first day was taken up by jury selection—and the six jurors deliberated for only 30 minutes, KIFI reports.
Disturbing Details of the Puppy’s Death

According to testimonies from witnesses during the brief trial, the farmer who had given the puppy to Crosland’s son told him it was sick and dying. “I honestly thought I was doing the right thing by putting it out of its misery,” Crosland told an investigator. The prosecution argued that the puppy may not have even really been sick.

I don’t know if it was brought it up during the trial, but it should be noted that there’s at least one animal hospital located less than a mile from Preston Junior High, where the puppy, if it really was dying, could have been humanely euthanized.

Instead, witnesses—who insisted Preston cares deeply about animals—said he put the puppy in the snapping turtle’s aquarium, which was filled with water. Witnesses said the puppy “paddled a few times, and then the turtle grabbed it and pulled it under the water,” KIFI reports. “The puppy drowned before the turtle started eating it.”

Although Crosland’s attorney moved that the case be dismissed because of the lack of evidence that the puppy suffered, the judge ruled this decision was best left to the jury.

And, yes, the jury somehow decided in 30 minutes that the puppy hadn’t suffered. After all, they and Crosland’s supporters had no problem with what the teacher did—so why should the little puppy have any problem with Crosland dumping him into an aquarium with a hungry, sharp-beaked snapping turtle?

The Idaho Humane Society (IHS) released a statement saying it was outraged and saddened by the verdict, and I’m sure that many of us who truly do care about animals feel exactly the same way.

The one upside, as the IHS points out, is that this case has shined an international spotlight on Idaho’s weak animal cruelty laws.

“This travesty does not create any new precedence for allowing cruelty but rather, will undoubtedly serve as a rallying cry for those who care passionately about the welfare of animals to renew their efforts in communities throughout Idaho to ensure vigorous enforcement of our cruelty laws and to improve these laws both at the state level as well as locally,” it said. “Additionally, this verdict will no doubt bring both national and even international condemnation of Idaho’s laws and the reputation of Idaho in general.”

Photo credit: East Idaho News/YouTube

7 comments on “Idaho Teacher Acquitted of Animal Cruelty for Feeding Puppy to Turtle | Care2 Causes

  1. If the puppy was deformed and dying it’s all the more reason that s/he needed to be treated with love and that much more horrifying. I guess they will be doing this to sick people and elderly soon? Northern Idaho is/was home base to Neo-Nazis and Klansman. Guess we shouldn’t be surprised. This looks to be the Morman part, though.

    Liked by 1 person

    • He is a Mormon. Mormon acquitted by what was probably a Mormon jury. This is the guy and his Mormon Bishop asking for money after their house burnt down. Same town, same name, science teacher so must be the same. See: People should complain to the Mormon LDS church or at least ask if they condone such cruelty to animals. On a side note: Just recently read that some Mennonites (who had moved to Mexico because they didn’t want kids to attend school) were running drugs from Mexico through the US to Canada. That makes me wonder if there aren’t some Mormons doing the same, considering that some of them moved to Mexico way back when to practice polygamy. One more reason that the area around Idaho National lab should be the final home to America’s nuclear waste. The others being climate, already had a nuclear accident and it is the only national lab currently promoting nuclear as its main job.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Thanks for the information! I went over to the GoFundMe…. I see they have a $200,000 goal and only raised a little over 16,000, not a very generous bunch of people are they? I can’t believe he didn’t have fire insurance!! I forgot to see if this happened after the puppy, that would be nice…. a little karma bit him!
        I’m going to do a little research and see if you can leave a message without dominating money…. if you can, I’m going to do a post for anybody that wants to leave a message about what they think of him, and lack of compassion of the Mormon religion, plus Ohio is a big hunting state, and that’s another big reason he got off and not fired!

        Liked by 1 person

        • You are welcome. That is the most horrid story I have ever heard of. Maybe write the national office for LDS in Salt Lake City. You meant Idaho rather than Ohio?, though I think the Mormons migrated from Ohio, originally. Being a “big hunting state” looks like it is against the teaching of their prophets. But, feeding a puppy to a turtle is much more cruel than shooting, if the hunter is a good shot. Many consider firing squad a humane death for humans, whereas this falls squarely under cruel and inhumane for any living being.

          Liked by 1 person

          • I’m having some strange things happening on my blog this comment totally I found it in my trash so I retrieved it, but the comment I gave you has totally disappeared now!

            As per my previous comment…I did mean Idaho not Ohio!
            I checked out that GoFundMe again, that was January 2015 and you can leave a comment without donating, someone did leave a comment about what he did to that puppy, but it didn’t seem to faze anyone and I wonder what good it will do to contact the national office since they must know what he did by now and he was found not guilty and charges dropped, It upset a few people but most said it was no big deal the puppy was sick and needed to be put out of its misery, they praise him for being a good teacher and the school never fired him, he would give his students extra credit for bringing in animals to feed to his turtle and snake! This puppy was given to a boy from a farmer that claimed the puppy was ill, first he put the puppy in the tank with the snake who didn’t bother, than he put the puppy in with the turtle who pulled it under the water and drown the puppy… Definitely sounds like a good place to dump nuclear waste, what a bunch of jerks!!!

            Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.