The Guardian view on friendly bacteria: an ally against plastic | Editorial | Opinion

Plastic bottles at a dump in Northern Thailand. And bacterium that can consume even one kind of plastic could become a desperately-needed ally.’ photograph: Rungroj Yongrit?EPA



Thanks to a genetically engineered enzyme, a bug that eats plastic bottles developed a much bigger appetite for our rubbish. It is a hopeful sign
Plastic bottles at a dump in northern Thailand
Plastic bottles at a dump in northern Thailand. ‘A bacterium that can consume even one kind of plastic could become a desperately needed ally.’ Photograph: Rungroj Yongrit?EPA

Evolution never sleeps. Before 1970 there can have been no significant bacteria that ate plastic, because there was not enough of that plastic in the world to sustain a population. But in 2016 a group of Japanese scientists discovered a new species, Ideonella sakaiensis, in the samples they were sifting from a bottle-recycling plant, that was able to attack and eat PET, the plastic used in most bottles, almost all of which ends up in landfill or dumped at sea, where it may last for centuries. Everything that rots in nature does so because it is being eaten by bacteria. Most plastics – among them PET – were considered totally impervious to bacterial attack, making them almost indestructible unless burned or crushed. So a bacterium that can consume even one kind of plastic could become a desperately needed ally in the struggle to stop the oceans being choked with plastic waste.

What has captured the imagination of the world is that a subsequent group of scientists, who were trying to understand on a molecular level how I sakaiensis breaks down and digests plastic bottles, found the enzymes that it uses and made a slightly different version of one to see what would happen. The new enzyme is much more efficient than the version found in nature, and works on more kinds of plastic. This kind of molecular tweaking of substances, already found in nature, is at the root of another recent scientific breakthrough, the Crispr-Cas9 technique for genetic engineering. It offers some hope that we can use technology to moderate and even to some extent to reverse the impacts that earlier technologies, such as those that make it easy to manufacture billions of tons of plastic, have had on the world around us.

This is going to be essential. The mass production and use of plastics has had such an effect on the Earth that some scientists, speculating wildly that there will still be people around to care about such things in the unimaginably distant future, have proposed the detection of plastic deposits as the best signal of the Anthropocene, the era in which human activity becomes the most powerful factor affecting life on Earth. One of the things this story shows is that our environment is not static and never has been. It is a dynamic system, in which changes of every sort have unintended consequences – PET was widely adopted partly because it seemed to have no ill effects on human health, at a time when no one asked how we would ever get rid of it – and every action produces an unexpected reaction, so that some bacteria learn to be resistant to antibiotics while others learn to feed off plastics. Even plastics have their uses to clean up pollution: they are used as sponges to clean up oil spills, although Australian scientists have just discovered a blend of sulphur and cooking oil that promises to work even better. There is no simpler world to which we can retreat – and for the sake of our children, we will simply have to manage these things better than our parents’ generations did.

6 comments on “The Guardian view on friendly bacteria: an ally against plastic | Editorial | Opinion

  1. PET is used in medical facilities for tubes and things. We need to ask why people feel they can’t drink water from the tap? Or if they are just too lazy to refill a bottle from a filter and need to get in a better habit? If we don’t ask that question then we will just replace the bottles with metal or glass which require mining and still need to be recycled. PET can be a renewable product, as well as recycled. The PET bottles can also be reused by an individual if they have a good design.

    Liked by 1 person

    • That would be great, we have to stop using the plastic bottles. I’m calling lazy and for some unknown reason people think that’s better water! I have a half gallon and a quart Igloo jugs, I fill with lots of ice and water from home, they stay ice cold all day, and when I put the water down for the dogs they all want to drink from that bowl, the pits love to eat the ice.

      Liked by 1 person

      • That’s a good idea! Sometimes local water really is bad (e.g. Lead, etc.) I think they don’t want to fix the water system because it costs money AND they want people to buy bottled water. The bottled water isn’t necessarily better, though. The Pur filters or Brita filters help a lot and filters can be put on the house, but they don’t get everything, even though they are supposed to get chlorine. The ones on the kitchen tap are especially easy to use. They used to have them for showers, too. However, we can’t really trust the bottling companies, either. In Europe they ozonate the water instead of putting chlorine, which is healthier than drinking water and showering water, etc., which smells like a swimming pool. Fairly cheap carbon filters like Pur and Brita pick up some of the radioactive materials along with chlorine and lead.

        Liked by 1 person

        • I guess it’s the world we live in anymore, they flushed our fire hydrants on Monday, we could not use that water until late afternoon… we have the Pure in the kitchen and ice maker, it would be nice to have the whole house, I can just imagine what that would cost! The last 3 years they have been replacing the water pipes in our Township and I’m definitely not looking forward to them coming through our street, what a mess… We’re crossing our fingers they don’t need to dig up our cement driveway they’ve been doing a lousy patch job on the sidewalks and it looks like they use field grass the patch up the yards.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.